Ye kong que (2015) Reviews

• Lovely artistic film but not for everyone

  dongqingsun2016-09-04

  Great film but not for simple romance seekers. Firstly congrats to the filmmakers for being nominated on the Montreal Filmfestival. The film is an interesting translation of the forgotten Chinese culture waved in the French romance. The philosophy of the film director is greatly reflected in the film with you have to see through in order to enjoy. It is definitely one of the lesser films that you have to watch multiple times to unravel all of its greatness. The director choose an unique editing manner which made the film little difficult to understand. The story was also complex as it reflected inner desires and conflicts. As the scenes and the main actress were stunning, the film was covered in deep sorrow. But it is clearly not a film suited for every public. If you don't like art-house films you probably would hate it. All in all, if you like artistic films that sets your mind to think and want to enjoy great beauty? WATCH!

  More

• A messy, randomly directed, edited pointless pretentious film

  BasicLogic2016-05-29

  This film is another living example of how the modern day Chinese movie makers, screenplay writers and directors trying so hard to do certain deeper and decent films but in the end, simply turned out to be pathetically lost their way of doing things right. What we got here was making a Chinese young woman to become a naturalized French, yet at the same time, still a 100% typical Chinese woman who tried so hard to get connected with the Chinese silk culture. Here we got a production with moronically scripted messy screenplay, the story-line was so unbalanced, the localities jumped around like blind frog between France and Hubei, China. The messy screenplay had forced the director to follow the pointless yet so falsely pretended as a deep soul-searching poetically and cosmetically nice film. But alas, all were lost in the translation! We saw the heroin encountered three males, one older and mature guy in Hubei, China, who was so pretentiously tried to play flute to the silkworms in the cocoons before sending them into the furnace. Then another guy, a tattoo artist lived in France, who ridiculously and so co-incidentally was the younger brother of the former mentioned guy in China. Then a much younger guy who fell for the French Chinese in the swimming pool.....blah, blah and blah, but all the scenarios and plots simply turned out to be so pointlessly stupid. The screenplay writer(s) just tried to use the silkworms and the silk to link a totally pointless messy film yet just turned out to be a "WTF?!" full-of-unanswered-questions big NADA. The editing of this film was also so messy and so confusing. Time and location sequence were just no-exist. Romance? Give me a break. There's nothing there either. Tattooing on the ankle and on the back of the heroin were just gimmicky shallowness to lure Peeping Toms to watch the rare exposed flesh of actress Liu, but the sensuality was also lost in the making of a pretentious and pointless messy film. We cursed after 45 minutes of any GPS could have guided us out of the mess and decided to bail out in the middle of the silk road.

  More